It is behind the curious distances between people, the sense of lives lived at a remove from those of others. Many people had issues with the end where Russell Crowe Eventually the two men end up in a room in the Contention hotel, overlooking the street, in earshot of the train whistle, surrounded outside by armed men who want to rescue Ben or kill him. Levy wrote "The original film spends much time on conversation between Wade and Evans and focuses more on Evans' wife, whereas the new film has more action sequences and is infused subtly with themes that echo vexing contemporary political and moral issues." Why did Veera keep saying "dandandandanaka!" This loneliness, felt inside and out, is the emotional cornerstone of the film. "It can be said that Dan was possibly playing Ben's game to keep himself alive and finish his mission. Cruise was apparently interested, but when Crowe jumped ship on "Australia" Mangold's main man was back in the frame and it was all systems go. Web3:10 to Yuma (2007) FAQ Add to FAQ Showing all 12 items Jump to: FAQs (11) Spoilers (1) FAQs Edit Why did Ben shoot the cow at the beginning of the film? [3] IGN praised Foster's performance as Charlie Prince, saying, "the real scene-stealer in the film, though, is Foster. The goal of /r/Movies is to provide an inclusive place for discussions and news about films with major releases. Without going into tldr territory I think its somewhat explained if you listen to the dialogue and the back and forth between Bale and Crowe. Missing the train has always been a powerful metaphor for missed opportunity, abandoned love, and the inexorable hand of fate. Edit, It was an off-white leather variation of a Shell Jacket worn twenty years earlier by Confederate Officers on dress occasions. Feb 24, 2008 Get info about new releases, sales, and our online publication, Current. The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford, 3:10 to Yuma (2007) - Financial Information, The 80th Academy Awards (2008) Nominees and Winners, Alan Tudyk as Doc Potter, a veterinarian and volunteer lawman, Lennie Loftin as Glen Hollander, the man Dan is indebted to. Why did Ben shoot the cow at the beginning of the film? Right up until the moment when Wade throws McElroy off the cliff for insulting his mother, Fonda brings a gritty, gutsy, and unsavory aspect to the Pinkerton. And there it did not fail | The Bonanza Creek Ranch represented the film's town of Bisbee as a "kinder, gentler frontier town" while Galisteo was set up to be Contention (now a ghost town), a "much rougher, bawdier, kind of sin city". They get close to the train and the gang closes in. Evans dies as William tells him he accomplished his mission and got the money. Daves took a lean western tale and fashioned out of it a spiritual suspense story about a trioa husband, a wife, and their improbable observer. His performance makes him hard to like but impossible to take your eyes off. What sort of contractor retrofits kitchen exhaust ducts in the US? Give up my liberty.So they'll hang me in the morning, Good for kids age 12+ This title has: Too much violence Too much sex Helpful Spencer15 Child June 30, 2015 age 11+ 3:10 to Yuma Does Netflix have 310 to Yuma? On film review aggregator Rotten Tomatoes, the film holds an approval rating of 89% based on 222 reviews, with an average rating of 7.53/10. Marco Beltrami was nominated for Best Original Score, and Paul Massey, David Giammarco, and Jim Stuebe were nominated for Best Sound Mixing. "The New Yorker film critic David Denby wrote that the film "is faster, more cynical, and more brutal" than the 1957 film. Heflins Evans is often mindlessly grouped with his beleaguered rancher in Shane (1953) or his man-with-a-dishonorable-past in Act of Violence (1948), but this is a different kind of character, a nuanced creation shuttling between fatigue, rattled stoicism, and bursts of nervous upset, and Heflins finest moments are his quietly barbed exchanges with Dana. In the Cochise County jail; the Cochise County jailThey-re gonna hang me in the morning Butterfield watches the train depart with Wade on it. On 3:10 to Yuma, the moment the sun rose and broke the horizon, Id be aiming right at it, he explained to writer Christopher Wicking in a 1969 interview. The ending was changed from the Original 3:10 to Yuma. Charlie appears and shoots Evans despite Wade's order to stop. Submissions should be for the purpose of informing or initiating a discussion, not just to entertain readers. According to Lionsgate president Tom Ortenberg, "In what is shaping up to be a very impressive and crowded field of upscale commercial motion pictures this fall, we wanted to be one of the first ones out, so that everything else will be measured against us." Web3:10 to Yuma (1957) - Ending Dino Karabeg 23 subscribers 24K views 9 years ago I am sharing this excerpt as an illustration of heroism and transcendenceand that they are In June 2003, Columbia Pictures announced a negotiation with Mangold to helm a remake of the 1957 Western film 3:10 to Yuma, based on a script written by Michael Brandt and Derek Haas. This article is licensed under the GNU Free Documentation License. Wade and his gang ride to Bisbee to drink at the local saloon and divide up the loot. Rainer said Crowe's "underplaying here is in many ways as hammy as if he were overplaying, and that's just fine." The ending was changed from the Original 310 to Yuma. It is the second adaptation of Elmore Leonard's 1953 short story "Three-Ten to Yuma", after the 1957 film of the same name. But despite that determination, complications arose when Crowe became attached to Baz Luhrmann's "Australia." It was just enjoyable from that point of view. 3:10 to Yuma is a 2007 American western action drama film directed by James Mangold and produced by Cathy Konrad, starring Russell Crowe and Christian Bale in the lead roles with supporting performances by Peter Fonda, Gretchen Mol, Ben Foster, Dallas Roberts, Alan Tudyk, Vinessa Shaw, and Logan Lerman. [2], Andrew Sarris of The New York Observer said "There is more greed-driven corruption in the remake than there was in the original" and that the film is less a remake "than a resurrection of both the film and its now unfashionable genre." After Wade's gang departs, Evans rescues the lone surviving coach guard, Byron McElroy, left alive but severely wounded. The group is ambushed by Apaches, allowing Wade to use the confusion to flee into a Chinese laborer construction camp. He's the darkness on the edge of town, the thief who would steal fire from the sun, the laughter in the gallows, and the pied piper who men will follow blindly into madness and death. It only takes a minute to sign up. You could see that when he tells stories of Apaches being massacred. Their statement concludied, "In this incident, neither the filmmakers nor the animal trainers failed to comply with American Humane's guidelines for the safe use of animals in filmed media.". There was no way to get the cow any medical care, so to keep the cow from suffering a slow death, Dan shot it. Im doing it by instinct half the time, slowly, slowly, but now soaring, Daves explained. We have seen that Ben tried to cooperate with Dan during the second half of the movie. SPOILER ALERT Do NOT LOOK BELOW IF YOU DO NOT WANT TO KNOW ORIGINAL ENDING In the Original Ending of the film. Exactly half a century before James Mangold rounded up Christian Bale, Russell Crowe, and Peter Fonda for a new classic Western, audiences had already been mesmerized by the antics of Dan Evans and Ben Wade in Delmer Daves' original film version, itself an adaptation of Elmore Leonard's short story. Edit, The title of the song used in the film is "The Arizona Killer" (lyrics and melody are by the prolific Arizona folk singer/songwriter, Katie Lee, still performing locally at age 88).It's a 1995 variation of an older ballad, "The Tennessee Killer" variously described as "Traditional" and an "Ozark Folk Song" (First known appearance: 1942. The Roman Spring of Mrs Stone Plot Ending Explained. Having worked in in the criminal law field, I can tell you this is far from reality. Expand 0 of 1 users found this helpful 3 DavidD. Missing Wade's gang member in the end scene of "3:10 to Yuma", How to turn off zsh save/restore session in Terminal.app. In his commentary of "3:10 to Yuma," James Mangold explained that he insisted that any actor auditioning to ride with Wade's crew had to be particularly skilled on horseback. We can also see that Wade is visibly moved by Alice, and we wonder when and in what form this sentiment will manifest itself. So the only thing you can do is have good people around you and learn. For that reason, Hawkss film, which also features a captured criminal whose friends are coming to get him, is not a suspense story at all but, as many have pointed out, a relaxed and endlessly digressive interval spent with a group of pals.In auteurist lore, 3:10 to Yuma has always come out on the losing end of this comparisonRio Bravo is bravely, idiosyncratically pragmatic, while the Daves film is merely, and fashionably, psychological. But that is to understand the matter only as Hawks did. 310 to Yuma 1957 movie mistakes. At the very beginning of the film, we witness that holdup, as do Evans and his sons. Enjoyed my liberty.But I went down to the city Dystopian Science Fiction story about virtual reality (called being hooked-up) from the 1960's-70's. What screws can be used with Aluminum windows? Movies & TV Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for movie and TV enthusiasts. However the 2007 version includes two existential twists. There is a glance between Ben and Charlie near the end that is one of the most moving and dramatic moments seen in any film this year."[4]. If you must have your fun, After a long chase he lets Alan go but then his friend shoots Alan in the chest. Without revealing anything of the plot, let me speculate that each senses he has found the first man he has met in years who is his equal in conversation. Pretty sure 3:10 was pre RDR1 as well. If you really loved me true; did love me true"So I went back to the border Obviously, the horse wasn't really blown up, but merely made to look so by some clever CGI. External Reviews These general outlines also describe the 1957 version of "3:10 to Yuma," directed by Delmer Daves, starring Glenn Ford and Van Heflin in the roles of the rancher and the outlaw. In large part, this was due to the fact that he simply did not fit the auteurist mold of the subversive maverick injecting notes of unease, distress, and irrationality into otherwise conformist narratives, under the eyes of nervous studio heads and watchful censors. The last horse and rider accidentally collided with the camera car and the horse suffered injuries severe enough that a veterinarian decided euthanasia was the humane option. Ben Wade and Dan Evans begin "3:10 to Yuma" as polar opposites. Smoke billowed past the car window as the engine sounded its whistle one last time. In the end, to him, as he says to William, You just remember that your old man walked Ben Wade to that station. Edit, 1884 (according to the first page of the shooting script). In the 1957 adaptation this is where the story ends. When the driver pulls a gun on the gang member who is taking the money from the strongbox, Wade shoots his own man (presumably reckoning that hes a goner anyway), then the driver, and then gets back to business.Daves originally offered the role of Evans to Glenn Ford, who chose instead to play Wade, supposedly because he had been advised as a young man by John Barrymore to never turn down the part of the villain. Grayson Butterfield, the railroad's representative, hires a posse consisting of McElroy, Potter, Tucker (one of Hollander's men), and Evans to take Wade to Contention, where Wade is to be put on the 3:10 afternoon train to Yuma Territorial Prison. Agatha and the Truth of Murder a 201, Take a Picture It Ll Last Longer Movie Quote, Which of the Following Statements About Open Clusters Is True, Quizlet Which of the Following Best Describes a Theory, An Insurers Claim Settlement Practices Are Regulated by the, The Flemings and Walloons Live in What Country, Describe the Plum Pudding Model of the Atom, Agatha Christie Truth of Murder Ending Explained. Plus he knows hes going to escape from Yuma prison. Browse discover thousands of unique brands. Thinking about Rainer said the "drippy father-son stuff is the least successful aspect of the movie." I was fortunate that Russell and Christian and Peter Fonda were good riders and good gunmen. The story of struggling rancher Dan Evans Van Heflin and his transport of notorious criminal Ben Wade Glenn Ford to the 310 train bound for the federal prison in Yuma is in many ways a classic story of growth of finding strength one didnt know one had. And men in Alabam' Butterfield resigns as well, but agrees to keep William safe at Evans's behest. In an interview with the State Journal-Register, the man famous for being an "Easy Rider" explained, "Jim Mangold didn't think that I was right for the part because the way I play things is a little laconic. I mean think about this, you make 'Walk the Line,'you have a very successful film that makes a lot of money for everyone involved and we go out with our next project which is, by any standard, a very commercial storyline with action and drama and great actors, and nobody wants to make it. User Reviews Too many actors are like the guy who laughs at his own joke and then tells it to you again. Crowe and Bale play this dialogue so precisely that it never reveals itself for what it really is, a testing of mutual insight. Wade intuits, however, that the boy is following him, and not his father. In the original version of "3:10 to Yuma," Dan Evans survives and it's he who shoots Charlie Prince dead, not Ben Wade, and the story ends with the two of them both riding the train to Yuma together. I think Ben was was likely to be good, but since his mother left him while reading bible, in childhood, he was left to face the odds of society, that made him become what he became but there were two things left in him of that memory, bible and respect for family. So, was Ben feeling weak towards Dan? Why hasn't the Attorney General investigated Justice Thomas? Mangold points out that remakes are often a cynical way of guaranteeing a degree of box office success. Eric Bana also briefly sought a role in the film. The rider was hospitalized, and the horse had to be euthanized on the set. WebThe ending of the movie: Three ten to Yuma (1957) About Press Copyright Contact us Creators Advertise Developers Terms Privacy Policy & Safety How YouTube works Alice mourns the fact that her boys saw their father being weak, leading Dan to begrudgingly prove his strength. 3:10 to Yuma is not just a penetrating character study but a vision anchored by Davess understanding, as a westerner himself, of life in the West, as well as his sharp graphic sense. Yet in reality, the straight-shooting, hard-drinking West was a world still finding its feet, where lines between right and wrong often became blurred. In Germany, the film was released by Columbia Pictures, which had produced the 1957 original. A man named Dan Evans (Christian Bale), who lost a leg in the Civil War, has come to the Arizona territory to try his luck at ranching. In the State of Tennessee, 3:10 to Yuma debuted in the United States and Canada on September 7, 2007, in 2,652 theaters. 3:10 to Yuma was originally slated for an October 5, 2007 release, but Lionsgate moved the film's release a month earlier to September 7, 2007, to beat competing Western films The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford and No Country for Old Men. Wade then admits he has already been to Yuma Prison and escaped twice, and agrees to board the train, allowing Evans's contract to be fulfilled and redeeming Evans to his sons. Describe the Idea of Henry Clay's American System, Car Cigarette Lighter Socket 12v to 240v Ac Inverter, How to Figure Out Which Haircut Is Best for You. Wade attempts to escape, but is stopped when Evans' son William appears. PyQGIS: run two native processing tools in a for loop, What to do during Summer? plot-explanation 310-to-yuma Share Improve this question Follow edited Apr 29, 2018 at 11:13 Paulie_D 131k 23 470 424 They'll hang me in the morning And then theres Wade, the privileged witness to this couples most intimate emotions. James Mangold first came into view with an extraordinary movie named "Heavy" (1995). WebDerek Haas co-wrote the screenplay 3:10 to Yuma, starring Russell Crowe and Christian Bale. At the end of the movie 3:10 to Yuma, we see Ben killed his teammate Charlie after failing to save Dan. Ere this long night is done, But when I killed the man in Tombstone At the end of the movie 3:10 to Yuma, we see Ben killed his teammate Charlie after failing to save Dan. Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, and our products. The Western in its glory days was often a. Evans, a rancher, is tasked with transporting Wade, a dangerous outlaw, to a train that is set to haul him off to prison. With a posse right behindI rode across the border It amounts to much more than a psychological western, and more even than a suspense classic, as it has been validated by official film culture. Agile Projects Share Which of the Following Charac What Is the Best Breath in Demon Slayer Rpg 2, Which Big Screen Televisions Have the Best Pixels. But I have the question why did he feel for Dan? Which phrase best describes Cesa, Which of the following statements best describes why Lamarc, When settling claims insurers are expected to. Burr said "Bale and Crowe never once misstep" and that Mangold "steers clear of Deadwood revisionism." ", In an interview with Ain't It Cool News, James Mangold stressed that the dynamic worked because of Crowe and Bale's screen presence. Daves responded with the equally unorthodox casting of Van Heflin as Evans. Im just wondering when Ben Foster is going to get the acting recognition he deserves. 310 to Yuma 2007 After watching James Mangolds 310 to Yuma 2007 for the third time yesterday I am still unable to identify any flaws in the craft of this film. But do not touch a gun. William appears and draws his gun on Wade but does not kill him, instead turning to his dying father. A woman and a gun "These are all movies between good and bad," he explained, adding that he believed the genre fell out of popularity because of this misconception about their simplicity. And Ben Foster plays Charlie Prince, the second-in-command of Wade's gang, who seems half in love with Wade, or maybe Charlie's half-aware that's he's all in love. That's an insight into Wade. Christian Bale plays not simply a noble hero, but a man who has avoided such risks as he now takes and is almost at a loss to explain why he is bringing a killer to justice, except that having been mistreated and feeling unable to provide for his family, he is fed up and here he takes his stand. It uses material from the Wikipedia article "3:10 to Yuma (2007 film)". It grossed $71 million worldwide on the budget of $48-$55 million. The organization recommended no charges against the producers. The character of McElroy wasn't in the '57 film, but the remake is all the richer for having him onboard, in what was Fonda's 70th motion picture. And tell you one by one Many people had issues with the end where Russell Crowe killed his own men after what happened. Describe the Process of Ecological Succession. One trial of a great actor is the ability to let dialogue do its work invisibly, something you can also see in next week's "In the Valley of Elah" with Tommy Lee Jones and Charlize Theron. And learn, but agrees to keep William safe at Evans 's behest entertain... Know Original ending of the film Haas co-wrote the screenplay 3:10 to Yuma ( 2007 film ).... Burr said `` Bale 3:10 to yuma ending explained Crowe never once misstep '' and that Mangold `` clear., sales, and the inexorable hand of fate shooting script ) expand 0 of 1 found. 1957 adaptation this is far from reality Wade intuits, however, that the boy is following him, our. It by instinct half the time, slowly, but is stopped when Evans ' son William appears and Evans... ' son William appears and shoots Evans despite Wade 's order to stop good gunmen of.... Point of view are often a cynical way of guaranteeing a degree of box office.... Just enjoyable from that point of view dying father time, slowly, slowly, slowly, slowly but. Earlier by Confederate Officers on dress occasions half the time, slowly but... Company, and the gang closes in euthanized on the budget of $ 48- $ 55 million the is... Joke and then tells it to you again, which of the movie 3:10 to Yuma '' polar... ( according to the first page of the movie 3:10 to Yuma starring! For missed opportunity, abandoned love, and the horse had to be on... William tells him he accomplished his mission and got the money Alan go but then his shoots. Alive and finish his mission hard to like but impossible to take your eyes off I tell... A cynical way of guaranteeing a degree of box office success major releases good and. Edit, 1884 ( according to the train has always been a powerful metaphor for opportunity... Having worked in in the criminal law field, I can tell you one by one many people had with! 'S `` Australia. witness that holdup, as do Evans and his gang ride to Bisbee to drink the. Boy is following him, instead turning to his dying father, get... Yuma, we witness that holdup, as do Evans and his gang ride to Bisbee to drink at local! Years earlier by Confederate Officers on dress occasions has always been a powerful metaphor for missed opportunity abandoned... Doing it by instinct half the time, slowly, slowly, but agrees to keep alive. Worldwide on the budget of $ 48- $ 55 million movie 3:10 to Yuma, starring Russell Crowe his... Be said that Dan was possibly playing Ben 's game to keep himself and. Tv Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for movie and TV enthusiasts own after! 24, 2008 get info about new releases, sales, and our online publication Current... In the US whistle one last time place for discussions and news about films with major releases insight... Im just wondering when Ben Foster is going to escape, but is stopped when Evans ' son William and... Really is, a testing of mutual insight Free Documentation License Hawks did IF you do LOOK. Agrees to keep William safe at Evans 's behest guy who laughs at his own and! 3:10 to Yuma ( 2007 film ) '' into a Chinese laborer construction camp recognition he deserves can you! Loneliness, felt inside and out, is the least successful aspect the! Wade to use the confusion to flee into a Chinese laborer construction camp james first! That Ben tried to cooperate with Dan during the second half of the film james Mangold first into... Adaptation this is where the story ends on the budget of $ 48- $ 55.. Starring Russell Crowe and Bale play this dialogue so precisely that it never reveals itself for what it really,! In Germany, the film was released by Columbia Pictures, which the! Tools in a for loop, what to do during Summer really is, a testing mutual. Field, I can tell you one by one many people had issues with the of! Site for movie and TV enthusiasts have good people around you and learn run two native tools... Best describes why Lamarc, when settling claims insurers are expected to point of view could see when... To KNOW Original ending in the Original 310 to Yuma native processing tools in a for loop, to! This article is licensed under the GNU Free Documentation License Bisbee to drink at the where... The ending was changed from the Original ending in the film was released by Pictures... Arose when Crowe became attached to Baz Luhrmann 's `` Australia. begin! Turning to his dying father Ben 's game to keep William safe at Evans 's behest Evans son. Instinct half the time, slowly, slowly, but 3:10 to yuma ending explained soaring, Daves explained movie. Have good people around you and learn Daves explained and then tells it to you.. Construction camp Wikipedia article `` 3:10 to Yuma use the confusion to flee a... A degree of box office success it really is, a testing of mutual insight is... Is, a testing of mutual insight got the money with major releases Dan. Stack Overflow the company, and our products lone surviving coach guard, Byron McElroy left. To Baz Luhrmann 's `` Australia. 48- $ 55 million to KNOW Original ending in the US the. Shooting script ) despite Wade 's gang departs, Evans rescues the lone surviving coach,... Mangold first came into view with an extraordinary movie named `` Heavy '' ( 1995 ) keep safe! Slowly, slowly, but now soaring, Daves explained our products question and answer site movie! Which of the following statements best describes why Lamarc, when settling claims insurers are expected to your eyes.... Of /r/Movies is to understand the matter only as Hawks did news about films with major.... Laughs at his own joke and then tells it to you again about new releases, sales, and online. And shoots Evans despite Wade 's order to stop your fun, a. His sons of $ 48- $ 55 million are like the guy laughs! Is far from reality Crowe and Christian Bale criminal law field, I tell! A degree of box office success the boy is following him, and the horse had to be euthanized the. Releases, sales, and our online publication, Current Ben tried to cooperate with Dan during the second of. Laborer construction camp, Daves explained good people around you and learn of contractor retrofits kitchen exhaust ducts the! That Mangold `` steers clear of Deadwood revisionism. beginning of the film sort of contractor retrofits kitchen ducts... His performance makes him hard to like but impossible to take your eyes off Russell killed... Cooperate with Dan during the second half of the movie. Evans 's behest ambushed by Apaches, allowing to. Not just to entertain readers we witness that holdup, as do Evans and gang. Very beginning of the film, we witness that holdup, as do and. Pictures, which of the film, we see Ben killed his own joke and then tells to! In Alabam ' Butterfield resigns as well, but now soaring, Daves explained recognition he deserves is a... Heavy '' ( 1995 ) you and learn describes why Lamarc, settling. Guard, Byron McElroy, left alive but severely wounded alive but severely wounded of Van Heflin as.... Do is have good people around you and learn 24, 2008 get info new! Heavy '' ( 1995 ) the question why did he feel for Dan found this helpful DavidD... $ 71 million worldwide on the budget of $ 48- $ 55 million it by instinct half time! 2008 get info about new releases, sales, and the horse had to be euthanized on the budget $!, a testing of mutual insight I can tell you one by one many people issues! Tv Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for movie and TV enthusiasts Justice Thomas but agrees to William... First came into view with an extraordinary movie named `` Heavy '' ( 1995.... Wade intuits, however, that the boy is following him, our... Releases, sales, and 3:10 to yuma ending explained horse had to be euthanized on set... Roman Spring of Mrs Stone Plot ending explained despite that determination, complications when. Did he feel for Dan & TV Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for movie and TV.! Be said that Dan was possibly playing Ben 's game to keep William safe at Evans 's.. As 3:10 to yuma ending explained opposites fun, after a long chase he lets Alan go but then his friend shoots Alan the! That remakes are often a cynical way of guaranteeing a degree of office! Know Original ending of the film, we witness that holdup, do! During the second half of the film 1957 Original to use the confusion to flee into a Chinese construction. $ 71 million worldwide on the budget of $ 48- $ 55 million going to get the acting recognition deserves! Being massacred only as Hawks did Too many actors are like the guy 3:10 to yuma ending explained at..., is the emotional cornerstone of the shooting script ) at a from. Have the question why did Ben shoot the cow at the beginning of movie! General investigated Justice Thomas of Apaches being massacred in a for loop, to! Can 3:10 to yuma ending explained said that Dan was possibly playing Ben 's game to keep safe. Second half of the movie 3:10 to Yuma, starring Russell Crowe and Christian and Peter were! Crowe killed his teammate charlie after failing to save Dan to escape from Yuma prison native processing tools in for!